
Magene PES P505 Base Power Meter Crankset
PowermeterThe Magene PES P505 is a budget spider-based power meter on Magene aluminium cranks with a 24 mm spindle, typically $200-300 in sales and about 638 g without chainrings. Owners find it accurate when calibrated, with some units needing 101-105% power scaling, and easy to install with Shimano bottom brackets; T47 internal and BB386 often do not clear the spider. The proprietary interface ties the P505 Base to Magene arms; the separate P505-S1103 spider fits 3-bolt cranks. Persistent issues are a loosening left arm (fixed with the newer two-piece preload bolt and threadlocker) and squeaking at the crank/spider interface. Magene has replaced squeaking arms, though without a new preload bolt. Replacement PES arms are not sold separately, so the options are the pricier TEO crankset or the half-price GeoID PM500. Chainrings must be 110 BCD; QED rings bundled with the meter must be the split version, as one owner received a one-piece ring that cannot mount on the spider. Firmware glitches are fixed with a magnet reset. L/R balance is only an estimate.
AI Summary
Pros
- Excellent value for money, often priced around $200-300 USD
- Accurate power readings when properly calibrated, comparable to Favero Assioma and smart trainers
- Easy installation for Shimano-compatible setups with straightforward setup process
more pros in the review
Cons
- Left crank arm preload bolt frequently works loose, requiring threadlocker or replacement with redesigned bolt
- Not compatible with T47 internal and BB386 bottom brackets due to spider clearance issues with some frames
- Proprietary interface locks P505 Base version to Magene cranks only, cannot be used with other cranksets
more cons in the review
Key Points
- Price typically $200-300 USD during sales (11.11 discounts available)
- Weight: Spider 112g, total system ~638g without chainrings
- 24mm steel spindle compatible with Shimano bottom brackets
more key points in the review

Magene PES P515 Base Power Meter Crankset
PowermeterThe Magene PES P515 is a spider-based power meter crankset (24 mm steel spindle, 110 BCD 4-bolt), the successor to the P505: about 25 g lighter, rated at 1% instead of 1.5%, with active temperature compensation and better T47 compatibility; the carbon TEO version uses a 29 mm spindle. It costs around EUR 250 and is bought from Magene's AliExpress store in Europe or Magene's site in the US, avoiding region-locked Chinese units. Owners find it accurate when calibrated (also with oval rings, thanks to continuous angular velocity measurement), easy to install with a 44 mm 16-notch lockring tool, and compatible with Shimano 105/Ultegra chainrings, GRX and many aftermarket rings; firmware updates (v0.118/v0.119) improved behaviour, though one user saw spikes after updating. The recurring problem is creaking or clicking under load that returns after a few thousand km. Magene says it comes from the crank-to-spider interface, replaced one unit under warranty, and owners silenced it by greasing that interface generously and torquing it fully; others report 4,000 miles without noise. Other niggles: a proprietary crank interface (Magene arms only), early one-piece preload bolts that got lost or stuck, an occasional lockring thread defect, narrow chainring bolt holes that make GRX chainring nuts awkward (Alugear bolts work), lost crank bolt O-rings, spacers needed on some frames, and patchy Bluetooth and customer support. A revised drive-side-bolt crankset was shown in Shanghai.
AI Summary
Pros
- Good value around EUR 250 with 1% claimed accuracy and temperature compensation
- Accurate when calibrated, also with oval chainrings
- Easy installation with standard tools and a 44 mm 16-notch lockring tool
more pros in the review
Cons
- Creaking or clicking under load after a few thousand km, which regreasing only fixes temporarily for some; Magene points to the crank-to-spider interface
- Proprietary crank interface: only Magene arms fit
- Early preload bolts were one-piece and got lost or stuck; replacements are hard to source
more cons in the review
Key Points
- 24 mm steel spindle; 110 BCD 4-bolt spider; TEO carbon version with 29 mm spindle
- About 25 g lighter than P505; claimed 1% accuracy; active temperature compensation
- Compatible with T47 (68 and 86 mm) and Shimano BSA BBs; spacers needed on some frames
more key points in the review