All Reviews

Community reviews from YouTube, forums, blogs, Reddit and users

Magene PES P505 Base Power Meter Crankset

Magene PES P505 Base Power Meter Crankset

Powermeter
Magene P505 PES Base Spider Powermeter

The Magene PES P505 is a budget spider-based power meter on Magene aluminium cranks with a 24 mm spindle, typically $200-300 in sales and about 638 g without chainrings. Owners find it accurate when calibrated, with some units needing 101-105% power scaling, and easy to install with Shimano bottom brackets; T47 internal and BB386 often do not clear the spider. The proprietary interface ties the P505 Base to Magene arms; the separate P505-S1103 spider fits 3-bolt cranks. Persistent issues are a loosening left arm (fixed with the newer two-piece preload bolt and threadlocker) and squeaking at the crank/spider interface. Magene has replaced squeaking arms, though without a new preload bolt. Replacement PES arms are not sold separately, so the options are the pricier TEO crankset or the half-price GeoID PM500. Chainrings must be 110 BCD; QED rings bundled with the meter must be the split version, as one owner received a one-piece ring that cannot mount on the spider. Firmware glitches are fixed with a magnet reset. L/R balance is only an estimate.

AI Summary

Pros

  • Excellent value for money, often priced around $200-300 USD
  • Accurate power readings when properly calibrated, comparable to Favero Assioma and smart trainers
  • Easy installation for Shimano-compatible setups with straightforward setup process

more pros in the review

Cons

  • Left crank arm preload bolt frequently works loose, requiring threadlocker or replacement with redesigned bolt
  • Not compatible with T47 internal and BB386 bottom brackets due to spider clearance issues with some frames
  • Proprietary interface locks P505 Base version to Magene cranks only, cannot be used with other cranksets

more cons in the review

Key Points

  • Price typically $200-300 USD during sales (11.11 discounts available)
  • Weight: Spider 112g, total system ~638g without chainrings
  • 24mm steel spindle compatible with Shimano bottom brackets

more key points in the review

Magene PES P515 Base Power Meter Crankset

Magene PES P515 Base Power Meter Crankset

Powermeter
Magene P515 PES Spider Powermeter

The Magene PES P515 is a spider-based power meter crankset (24 mm steel spindle, 110 BCD 4-bolt), the successor to the P505: about 25 g lighter, rated at 1% instead of 1.5%, with active temperature compensation and better T47 compatibility; the carbon TEO version uses a 29 mm spindle. It costs around EUR 250 and is bought from Magene's AliExpress store in Europe or Magene's site in the US, avoiding region-locked Chinese units. Owners find it accurate when calibrated (also with oval rings, thanks to continuous angular velocity measurement), easy to install with a 44 mm 16-notch lockring tool, and compatible with Shimano 105/Ultegra chainrings, GRX and many aftermarket rings; firmware updates (v0.118/v0.119) improved behaviour, though one user saw spikes after updating. The recurring problem is creaking or clicking under load that returns after a few thousand km. Magene says it comes from the crank-to-spider interface, replaced one unit under warranty, and owners silenced it by greasing that interface generously and torquing it fully; others report 4,000 miles without noise. Other niggles: a proprietary crank interface (Magene arms only), early one-piece preload bolts that got lost or stuck, an occasional lockring thread defect, narrow chainring bolt holes that make GRX chainring nuts awkward (Alugear bolts work), lost crank bolt O-rings, spacers needed on some frames, and patchy Bluetooth and customer support. A revised drive-side-bolt crankset was shown in Shanghai.

AI Summary

Pros

  • Good value around EUR 250 with 1% claimed accuracy and temperature compensation
  • Accurate when calibrated, also with oval chainrings
  • Easy installation with standard tools and a 44 mm 16-notch lockring tool

more pros in the review

Cons

  • Creaking or clicking under load after a few thousand km, which regreasing only fixes temporarily for some; Magene points to the crank-to-spider interface
  • Proprietary crank interface: only Magene arms fit
  • Early preload bolts were one-piece and got lost or stuck; replacements are hard to source

more cons in the review

Key Points

  • 24 mm steel spindle; 110 BCD 4-bolt spider; TEO carbon version with 29 mm spindle
  • About 25 g lighter than P505; claimed 1% accuracy; active temperature compensation
  • Compatible with T47 (68 and 86 mm) and Shimano BSA BBs; spacers needed on some frames

more key points in the review