
New Chinese groupset under scrutiny - Magene QED
Trace Velo
28 agosto 2025
Firstly MASSIVE thankyou to Petr from Cyclists Hub for breaking this story on youtube, you can find his video here:
https://youtu.be/ZZtM4w3Qhsw?si=gMOvHBFtivnOHR3r
A Chinese brand Magene recently released a new electronic road bike groupset, featuring hydraulic disc brakes under their QED line of products. I saw it in the flesh at both the Shanghai bike show. and Eurobike this year, and my first impressions were very good.
It seemed like an incredibly polished groupset, and I was extremely excited to try it out. It is currently only being sold in China, but they do have plans to make it available in other markets. However, someone using the groupset in China faced a problem with the braking system recently, causing him to lose control and he ended up breaking his leg in a crash.
Petr and his interviewee Mel speculated that the cause could have been something to do with the oil reservoir within the shifter. Essentially if the reservoir is not big enough, then as the brake pads wear, the pistons will eventually bottom out, and you will loose braking.
This is a failure mode I haven't even considered, so in this episode I will briefly discuss the issue, and then run some other Chinese groupsets from L-TWOO, Sensah, and Wheeltop, through a test to see if they also face any issues.
*MAGENE ADDITIONAL INFO*
Magene have not yet released the english version of the investigation report, once it is available (probably tomorrow - 29/08/2025) I will post some links here.
Timestamps:
00:00 – Intro and QED groupset issue
01:23 – Braking issue explanation
02:50 – Testing Shimano
06:29 – Testing L-TWOO R9
07:22 – Testing Sensah Empire HRD
07:52 – Testing L-TWOO eRX
09:56 – Prototype groupset brake failure
11:39 – Testing Wheeltop EDS TX
12:10 – Conclusion
14:32 – Bonus clip - Magene Statement
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/tracevelo/
Email:
tracevelouk@gmail.com
Please note:
I am not a professionally trained bike mechanic. There can be risks associated with using products that are unbranded, untested, or come from sources where the provenance is unknown. Please talk to a qualified bike mechanic if you are in any doubt.
In essence, be careful, do your research, and cycle safe!!!
Keywords: Magene QED,Brake failure,Disc brake failure,Bicycle disc brake failure,Road bike disc brake,Disc brake issues,Chinese road bike groupsets,magene,hydraulic disc brake,Chinese groupset,Chinese electronic groupset,Sensah HRD,Sensah Empire HRD,L-TWOO R9 Disc brakes,L-TWOO R9 Disc,L-TWOO Erx,Disc brake test,Bicycle disc brake test
Componenti menzionati
Magene QED GroupsetMagene QED Groupset
Creato: 29 marzo 2026Il recensore discute un problema di sicurezza segnalato con il gruppo Magene QED, in cui un utente avrebbe sperimentato un guasto ai freni con circa un terzo del materiale delle pastiglie rimanente, causando un incidente e una gamba rotta. Il recensore non può testare personalmente il gruppo poiché è disponibile solo in Cina, ma ipotizza che il problema possa coinvolgere una capacità del serbatoio insufficiente o difficoltà di spurgo. La dichiarazione ufficiale di Magene afferma che si trattava di un caso isolato causato da un utilizzo specifico, non di un difetto di progettazione.
Riepilogo IA
Pros
- Il gruppo sembra davvero bello e rifinito
- Tutto sembra ben rifinito
Cons
- Segnalato guasto ai freni con materiale delle pastiglie ancora significativo
- Presumibilmente ha causato un incidente e una gamba rotta
- Attualmente disponibile solo in Cina
- Potenziale problema di progettazione con la capacità del serbatoio o lo spurgo
- Minaccia la fiducia nei prodotti ciclistici cinesi